Sunday, June 29, 2014

J-20 vs. F-35, One Analyst's Perspective | Defense Tech

J-20 vs. F-35, One Analyst's Perspective | Defense Tech
J-20 vs. F-35, One Analyst's Perspective

With all the hoopla about China's new fifth-gen fighter this week, we asked Teal Group aviation analyst Richard Aboulafia for his take on how serious a threat the J-20/J-XX  is to the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter in air-to-air combat and as a competitor on the global fast jet market.

Rumor has it the J-20 is designed to take on the air superiority-focused F-22 Raptor. But remember, now that the F-22 is ending production and is banned for export sales, the F-35 will be the fifth-gen mainstay of the United States and numerous allies.

Here's what Richard has to say on the matter:

I would gauge a modern combat aircraft's capabilities by looking at the following features:

1.      Access to offboard space, ground, and air-based sensors, particularly a capable AEW/AWACS system with a well-trained crew and robust data links.

2.      Effective sensor fusion to allow the pilot to make use of all this information, as well as information from onboard sensors.

3.      An integrated EW system.

4.      An AESA radar with a high level of reliability.

5.      Training and doctrine necessary to make effective use of all this data and equipment.  Plenty of flight hours for pilot flight training, too.

6.      Powerful engines (ideally capable of supercruise), with a high mean time between overhaul and failures.

7.      An airframe with low-observable characteristics.

8.      A robust air-to-air refueling capability (equipment, readiness, training).

9.      Sophisticated and reliable precision guided weaponry.

10.  A robust software and hardware upgrade roadmap, to keep this plane effective in 5, 10, and 30 years.

11.  Maintenance procedures in place to keep the plane operating with a high mission-capable rate.  And of course equipment that has been designed with easy access for maintenance and easy access for electronic diagnostic tools, and ideally a sophisticated health-usage monitoring system (HUMS).

This list is not in any particular order of magnitude.  And I'm sure I've missed quite a few other key items.

The J-20 offers one item from this list (#7).  I'm not convinced that the PLAAF has any other items from this list, although China seems to be making some progress with #9.

It's kind of fun to watch the world fixate on this one item (#7).  Then again, I still enjoy air shows, too.  Pugachev's Cobra maneuver, for example.  Drives the crowd wild.  Relevance to modern combat?  Zero.

As for the F-35, it certainly has its problems, especially regarding the price tag.  But most, if not all, of the customers and partners are sophisticated enough to have a list that's a lot more comprehensive than the one above.  And I'm sure the appearance of item #7  as a prototype in PLAAF markings affects exactly none of their thinking.


Stolen F-35 Secrets Now Showing Up in China's Stealth Fighter | Washington Free Beacon

Stolen F-35 Secrets Now Showing Up in China's Stealth Fighter | Washington Free Beacon

Stolen F-35 Secrets Now Showing Up in China's Stealth Fighter

Photo comparison of the U.S. F-35 left and Chinese J-20. / Chinese website

Photo comparison of the U.S. F-35 left and Chinese J-20. / Chinese website

BY:

A cyber espionage operation by China seven years ago produced sensitive technology and aircraft secrets that were incorporated into the latest version of China's new J-20 stealth fighter jet, according to U.S. officials and private defense analysts.

The Chinese cyber spying against the Lockheed Martin F-35 Lightning II took place in 2007 under what U.S. intelligence agencies codenamed Operation Byzantine Hades, a large-scale, multi-year cyber program that targeted governments and industry.

Defense officials said the stolen data was obtained by a Chinese military unit called a Technical Reconnaissance Bureau in the Chengdu province. The data was then passed to the state-run Aviation Industry Corp. of China (AVIC).

An AVIC subsidiary, the Chengdu Aircraft Industry Group, used the stolen data in building the J-20, said defense and intelligence officials familiar with reports of the illicit tech transfer.

Newly unveiled J-20 / Chinese website

The newly unveiled J-20 jet fighter / Chinese website

Pentagon technology security officials in 2011 opposed a joint venture between ....

Article: This Site Shows Who Is Hacking Whom Right Now — And The US Is Getting Hammered


This Site Shows Who Is Hacking Whom Right Now — And The US Is Getting Hammered
http://www.businessinsider.com/norse-hacking-map-shows-us-getting-hammered-2014-6

Article: The Story About Amazon's Jeff Bezos Eating Octopus For Breakfast Is Symbolic Of His Business Strategy


The Story About Amazon's Jeff Bezos Eating Octopus For Breakfast Is Symbolic Of His Business Strategy
http://www.businessinsider.com/jeff-bezos-matt-rutledge-profile-2014-6?op=1